Geoffrey of Monmouth
Historian, Mythographer, Kingmaker?
Mark Adderley
11/13/20265 min read


Between his emergence in early medieval British tradition and the middle of the twelfth century, Arthur was a shadowy figure, belonging more to the strange world of mythology than to history. He was well known in Welsh storytelling, but little regarded among the English, who occupied the country next door to Wales, and scarcely known across the English Channel. This was all to change in about 1138.
Around that year a book began to circulate that revolutionized Arthurian literature: the Historia regum Britanniae (The History of the Kings of Britain), by Geoffrey of Monmouth. It was an instant bestseller—by medieval standards, at any rate—and did more than any earlier surviving work to make Arthur a figure of European fame. The Arthur most of us recognize today owes a great deal to Geoffrey, although he is not quite the Arthur whom Geoffrey actually wrote about.
The man from Monmouth
Geoffrey (not Monmouth—that was his home town, not his name) lived in England, with strong connections to the Welsh borderlands. He appears in records associated with Walter, Archdeacon of Oxford, and sometimes called himself magister, suggesting a man of learning, perhaps a teacher. In 1152 he was consecrated bishop of St Asaph, though political unrest seems to have prevented him from taking possession of his see. He died in 1154 or 1155.
Geoffrey’s writings reveal a remarkable fascination with Britain’s legendary past. He composed the Prophecies of Merlin, which he incorporated into his History, and later wrote the Life of Merlin, a poem drawing on traditions quite different in tone from those of the familiar Arthurian romances. But it was his History that made his reputation.
He lived in interesting times. Less than a century earlier, England had been conquered by the Normans, who were still attempting to extend their power in Wales and Scotland. When Henry I died in 1135, his nephew Stephen seized the throne despite earlier oaths supporting Henry’s daughter Matilda. The ensuing struggle for the crown produced years of rebellion and civil war. A divided kingdom, Geoffrey’s contemporaries knew, was vulnerable both to internal enemies and to ambitious neighbours. That is also one of the strongest themes of his History.
A history of Britain—more or less
The History begins not with Arthur but with Brutus, a descendant of the Trojan hero Aeneas, who accidentally kills his father, goes into exile, and eventually settles in the island that, according to Geoffrey, takes its name from him. Thereafter Geoffrey traces a long procession of British kings, some heroic, some disastrous. Among them is Leir, whose family tragedy would much later become the subject of a rather famous play by Shakespeare.
Geoffrey works on an enormous scale. He gives Britain an ancient and dignified past that can stand beside the histories of Rome and Troy, while showing how the fate of a kingdom may depend upon the virtues and failings of its rulers. Scripture, Roman history, and Virgil’s Aeneid all help shape his story. The result is not history in the modern scholarly sense. But neither is it simply a collection of entertaining fables: it is an imaginative account of what makes a nation, and what can destroy it.
For his source, Geoffrey claimed to be translating a very ancient book in the British language, lent to him by Walter of Oxford. Modern scholars have good reasons to doubt that the book existed in the form Geoffrey describes, but this should not obscure his genuine debt to Welsh historical and legendary traditions. He also drew on earlier writers, including Gildas, Bede, and the History of the Britons. His skill lay in making disparate materials into a single, absorbing narrative.
An Arthur you may not recognize
The most important thing about the History, for the future of literature at least, is that roughly a fifth of it is devoted to King Arthur. It offers the first extended, continuous account of his career to survive. Yet it differs from the versions that later became familiar in a number of striking ways.
For one thing, there is no sword in the stone, and no contest over the crown. Arthur becomes king at fifteen, succeeding his father Uther Pendragon, and promptly embarks upon a career of conquest that reminds one of Alexander the Great. He subdues not only the comparatively obvious France and neighbouring territories, but the rather unlikely Iceland and Norway. He is not principally a king of romance, presiding over quests and tournaments. He is a conqueror.
For another, there is no Lancelot. Guinevere is accused of betraying Arthur with Mordred, his nephew, whom Arthur has left in charge of Britain while he goes to war against the Roman leader Lucius. Arthur’s campaigns are initially successful, but news arrives that Mordred has seized the throne and taken Guinevere as his wife. Arthur returns to recover his kingdom. Mordred is killed, but Arthur himself is mortally wounded and carried to the island of Avalon to be healed. Geoffrey never tells us plainly that Arthur dies. That tantalizing uncertainty would prove remarkably fertile for later writers.
This Arthur is magnificent, but also troubling. His achievements depend upon war and conquest, and his empire is frail enough that it cannot survive treachery at home. The grandeur of his reign is inseparable from its catastrophe. Geoffrey gives us not merely a legendary hero, but an example of the fragility of worldly power.
The space Geoffrey left behind
Yet Geoffrey of Monmouth left an extraordinary opportunity for his successors. Between Arthur’s conquests in Europe and his fateful campaign against Rome lies a period of twelve years of peace about which Geoffrey tells us comparatively little. What was happening at Arthur’s court during those years? What sort of adventures might his companions have undertaken?
Poets of the later twelfth century were only too willing to provide answers. Writers such as Chrétien de Troyes developed the stories of knights, quests, love, and conflicting loyalties that we now associate with Arthurian romance. The Round Table and much of the world of Camelot grew through a long process of retelling, of which Geoffrey was a decisive early stage—not its final author.
That, finally, is why Geoffrey is worth reading. His Arthur may seem unfamiliar to someone raised on Lancelot, Guinevere, and the Grail, but the History has ambitions and pleasures of its own: battles, betrayals, marvels, magnificent speeches, and the rise and fall of kingdoms. Geoffrey gave Britain a grand legendary past and later storytellers a world they could endlessly explore. Whether we believe his history is quite another matter.
Footnote: Although I have used the title Historia regum Britanniae (History of the Kings of Britain) throughout, there is now an argument first advanced by Michael D. Reeve and accepted by many subsequent scholars, that De gestis Britonum (On the Deeds of the Britons) reflects Geoffrey’s intentions more accurately.
Further Reading
Barron, W. R. J. “Geoffrey of Monmouth’s Historia Regum Britanniae.” The Arthur of the English: The Arthurian Legend in Medieval English Life and Literature. Ed. W. R. J. Barron. Rev. ed. Cardiff: U of Wales P, 2001. 11-18.
Geoffrey of Monmouth. The History of the Kings of Britain. Trans. Michael A. Faletra. Peterborough, Ont.: Broadview, 2008.
Geoffrey of Monmouth. The History of the Kings of Britain: An Edition and Translation of the De gestis Britonum. Ed. Michael D. Reeve. Trans. Neil Wright. Arthurian Studies 69. Boydell and Brewer, 2007.
Parry, John J., and Robert A. Caldwell. “Geoffrey of Monmouth.” Arthurian Literature in the Middle Ages. Ed. R. S. Loomis. Oxford: Clarendon, 1959. 72-93.
Smith, Joshu Byron, and, Georgia Henley, eds. A companion to Geoffrey of Monmouth. Brill, 2020.
Image: "King Arthur and Sir Mordred at the Battle of Camlann," by William Hatherell (1928). Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.
Address
716 Colonial Hills Drive
Lillington, NC 27546
Contacts
605-655-4346
markadderley@sbcglobal.net
